Absurd Universal Credit flaws stop vulnerable people getting help from loved ones to manage benefits, leaving 100,000s struggling, and some risking benefits cuts
- New research by the Money and Mental Health Policy Institute — a charity set up by Martin Lewis — shows 100,000s of people experiencing high levels of mental distress may struggle to get support to effectively manage their Universal Credit accounts and avoid sanctions (reduced benefits).
- It found that, while over half those with mental health problems need help with Universal Credit from family and friends, only one in ten has managed to nominate a regular helper.
- Claimants are effectively being set up to fail, due to absurd and needless design flaws in the process to nominate a helper.
- That results in many claimants struggling alone with the arduous ongoing Universal Credit admin and bureaucracy.
- This substantially increases the risk of Universal Credit sanctions or even being cut off by the Department for Work and Pensions.
- Money and Mental Health is concerned this could escalate when the furlough scheme ends later this year, with more Universal Credit claimants likely.
- The charity is calling on the government to take urgent action to fix the Universal Credit design problems, so anyone who needs help from loved ones to manage their benefits can get it.
Today, the Money and Mental Health charity is launching a new campaign — Set Up To Fail. The campaign calls for urgent action from the government to fix the design flaws in the Universal Credit system to ensure that anyone who needs help with Universal Credit can get it — instead of being inadvertently set up to fail by the system.
This is on the back of new research showing that around 1.3m people experiencing high levels of mental distress are currently receiving or applying for Universal Credit (1). The charity’s research shows that without support, many people with common symptoms of mental health problems — such as difficulties understanding complex information and remembering appointments — struggle to deal with the ongoing admin and bureaucracy required to get Universal Credit payments.
This includes filling in complex forms, dealing with correspondence from the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) and appealing decisions about their benefits.
In turn, this leaves people at risk of being sanctioned by the DWP, or being cut off from Universal Credit payments altogether. It also causes unnecessary anguish for people who are already struggling with their mental health, and for their carers. Money and Mental Health estimates that 100,000s of people experiencing high levels of mental distress may struggle to get the support they need with Universal Credit (1).
The research shows that the Universal Credit system is setting vulnerable people up to fail because to nominate someone to support them, they have to navigate similarly complex and unclear processes to those that they were trying to get help with in the first place.
In a survey of over 230 people with mental health problems who have claimed Universal Credit, over half (57%) said they have needed help from family or friends to manage their Universal Credit account. Just over a quarter (27%) said they need that help always or often, and yet only one in ten (10%) has managed to give permission for someone to help regularly (2).
Specific problems which make it hard for people to get help with Universal Credit include:
- The DWP doesn’t advertise that people can give permission to a loved one to help manage their Universal Credit account, or what the process is to set that up through the Universal Credit website.
- To nominate a loved one as a regular helper, the claimant needs to tell DWP details of every single task they might need help with, and every piece of information they want to share, but without any prompts or guidance.
- In theory people can also call the DWP to explain what help they need from a loved one, but this is not a viable option for many people with mental health problems. Money and Mental Health’s research shows that more than half (54%) of UK adults who’ve had mental health problems say they have severe difficulties in using the phone (3), often leading to panic attacks, heart palpitations and spiralling anxiety.
Gary, who took part in the charity’s research, said: ‘In the last year I was made redundant after being with a company for more than 23 years, and all the stress and worry has just come to the surface. I found the process of managing Universal Credit just horrendous and tough to follow, nothing is ever explained to you. At the moment I find it tough to deal with people as it’s hard to talk.
“I can’t deal with the messages from the DWP myself, I need my wife’s help, but we can’t set it up for her to receive notifications about the account. We’ve filled all the forms in but it feels like a trap door assessment, if you answer something slightly wrong you fall through and that’s it, they’ll take the money away. It’s like the system’s designed to trip you up to fail.’
Martin Lewis, Chair and Founder of the Money and Mental Health Policy Institute, said:
“It sounds like a scene from a spoof. People who are entitled to Universal Credit, sometimes due to mental health problems, which impact their ability to fill in forms or process complex information, are allowed to nominate someone to help them with the admin needed to keep receiving benefits. Yet to do that, they must go through a complex process which requires them to do the exact things they need help with in the first place. If they don’t manage it, they ultimately risk being sanctioned or losing all financial help.
“I don’t believe this is a deliberate attempt to set people up to fail. Yet that is the practical outcome for some. This is one Universal Credit problem the government can easily fix, by providing people with the right advice on how to nominate a loved one to help them, and by making the process to do it much easier, simpler and user-friendly.”
“And with more and more people likely to move on to Universal Credit when the furlough scheme ends in September, there is no time to waste. We’re calling on the government to act now so that everyone can get the help they need with Universal Credit.”
The Set Up To Fail campaign is calling on government to simplify the process that people have to complete to get support from a loved one with Universal Credit by:
- Providing people with clearer advice on what information they need to share with the DWP to get support from a loved one, and the correct process for doing so through the Universal Credit website.
- Making this online process much more accessible and user-friendly, by adding prompts and drop down menus to guide people
- Giving people more flexible options to share information about their Universal Credit account with loved ones – for example, the option to give a friend or relative view-only access to your Universal Credit account, or to allow loved ones to get notifications about your account.
The report published today makes a series of recommendations to government; relatively straightforward changes that could make a big difference in ensuring that people can get help from loved ones with managing their Universal Credit account, instead of being inadvertenetly set up to fail.
Money and Mental Health’s Set Up To Fail campaign has been backed by eight national charities from across the mental health and advice sectors, including Mind, the Royal College of Psychiatrists, Rethink Mental Illness, Turn 2 Us, the Money Charity and Advice UK.
- To set up an interview with Martin Lewis, or for any other media enquiries, please contact Brian Semple, Head of External Affairs at Money and Mental Health, on 07595 439 638 / 07935 216 804 or firstname.lastname@example.org
|NOTES TO EDITORS
About the Money and Mental Health Policy Institute
The Money and Mental Health Policy Institute is an independent charity set up by Martin Lewis, and committed to breaking the link between financial difficulty and mental health problems. We conduct research, develop practical policy solutions and work in partnership with both those providing services and those using them to find what really works. www.moneyandmentalhealth.org
The report and campaign were kindly sponsored by Lloyds Bank Foundation for England & Wales. The Money and Mental Health Policy Institute retains complete editorial independence over this work.